T.I.M.E

Chat Archive




Chat on B-school selection!
(Chat Transcript)


adarash : SIR PLEASE TELL ABOUT THE CHOICE BETWEEN IIMB PGPBA AND IIML PROVIDED A LIITLE BIT OF INCLINATION TOWARDS FINANCE
siddhartharora : PGPBA is a specialised course and hence if you require Finance only go for core courses. Otherwise it is a brilliant course and tags of IIM B and L mean a lot


shuvam : SIR WHAT ARE THE COLLEGE CHOICES OTHER THAN IIMS AND ISB B SCHOOLS
lakshmymenon : If you're looking at the B-schools in the same league as the top IIMs, you have FMS, SP Jain, XLRI, IIT Mumbai & Delhi, MDI Gurgaon, IIFT etc.


manas : SIR AFTER, SEPARATION OF IIFTD AND IIFTK PLACEMENT, IS IIFTK WORTH IT?
siddhartharora : It still remains a good Institute and hence will have decent placements


pty : PLEASE GIVE THE ORDER OF PREFERENCE FOR THESE: LBSIM(NON CORE), BIMTECH (CORE), SIDTM, GLIM GURGAON, WELINGKAR (NON CORE), FORE DELHI (NON CORE)
siddhartharora : Vist https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation Also, core is recommended over no core until you have special interest in the field


stats : CAN YOU SHARE THE VIEWS OF IIM EDUCATIONAL LOANS?ALL BANKS INTEREST RATE IS >10% . IS EVERYONR BUY LOANS WITH THESE INTEREST RATES OR ANY BANKS WITH LOW RATES?
siddhartharora : rates depend on many things, also this is unsecured loan and hence rates are bit higher. SBI typically gives the best rate and all IIMs are already approved by them, so check with them.


adarash : SIR WHAT IS THE EXPECTED CUTOFF FOR ISB ROUND 2 PGP-YL PROVIDED I HAVE 9/9/9 PROFILE AND A GOLD MEDAL FROM NIT ALLAHABAD ALSO SIR DOES TIME HAVE ANY SERVICE SO THAT I COULD GET MY ISB ESSAYS REVIEWED?
siddhartharora : Since the course is offered first time, we are still waiting and watching for cut off. For getting essays evaluated, please contact your centre, they will help.


stats : ALL IIMS HAVE INTERNSHIP , WE GENERALLY HEARD . HOW LONG WE HAVE PAID INTERNSHIP IN 2 YEARS MBA ? HOW THE CLASS AND WORKS TAKE PLACE?MORNING WORK?AFTERNOON CLASS ? LIKE THAT
lakshmymenon : Internships are usually for 2 months or so - typically in the summer break after the first year. There are no classes during that period - internships may be in any city, and you will have to be based there. For the remaining part of the course, you will not be able to work as you'll have regular classes through the day.


adarash : SIR ONE QUESTION REGARDING BSCHOOL INTERNSIPS LIKE IN THE SUMMERS IF I DONT HAVE ANY BACGROUND RELATED TO FINANCE THEN DO TOP FIRM LIKE GS,JP SHORTLIST THESE TYPE OF PEOPLE ALSO OR WE NEED TO HAVE ATLEAST A CFA
philipthomas : Though there is no such rule or guideline , it is customary for companies to select / prefer those who do have some exposure to the specialisation related to the internship.


bhargav : SIR I AM FROM CIVIL ENGINEERING BACKGROUND (UG) AND I WANT TO DO MBA INSTEAD OF MTECH, IS THERE ANY RELATED STREAM TO IN MBA COURSE LIKE INFRASTRUCTURE
lakshmymenon : Anybody can do general MBA programmes such as Marketing, Finance etc. irrespective of their graduation subject. While NICMAR offers MBA in construction management, MBAs from top Bschools are rated much higher and give you much better career opportunities. Infrastructure companies do participate in placements in most top Bschools. Even if you start your career in other sectors after MBA, you can always move to the sector of your choice later. It is always safer to go for a general programme from a premier B school.


dhruvil : I GOT 224 IN NMAT. MY PROFILE IS 7/8/8 WITH 9 MONTHS WORKEX IN CA FIRM AND 12 MONTHS WORKEX IN FAMILY BUSINESS.
siddhartharora : What is your query


stats : WHEN WILL THE IIM RESULTS WILL BE ANNOUNCED? HOW MANY DAYS WITHIN WE WANT TO PAY THE FEES AND JOIN THE COLLEGE . WHICH MONTH , THE COLLEGE WILL START?
lakshmymenon : Results will come by end March-April. Classes may start by mid May-early June.


dhruvil : I GOT 224 IN NMAT. MY PROFILE IS 7/8/8 WITH 9 MONTHS WORKEX IN CA FIRM AND 12 MONTHS WORKEX IN FAMILY BUSINESS. I HAVE GIVEN INTERVIEW IN TAPMI AND NMIMS AND I DON'T THINK INTERVIEW WENT VERY WELL FOR ME AND I HAVE IFMR INTERVIEW COMING UP BUT IT ALSO DOESN'T GO WELL SO WHICH COLLEGE SHOULD I GO FOR AS MY BACKUP OPTION BECAUSE I CAN'T WASTE THIS YEAR. I AM CONSIDERING ITM AS MY BACKUP OPTION. SO I JUST WANTED TO KNOW YOUR OPINION ON THIS
lakshmymenon : First of all, please be more confident about yourself. Prepare well for the IFMR interview. Secondly, you scored well in your exams this year - so why not give it another shot in case you do not get a good college? You can always take up a job in the meanwhile. Joining a college with a much lower rating than NM, TAPMI etc. would not be very wise if you look at the long term implications. Repeating CAT to get into a top B-school is not a waste - many students do so! The brand does matter after all. For now, please focus on IFMR. Do not take hasty decisions - you can do much better. Good luck.


adarash : SIR PLEASE GIVE SOME TIPS FOR PREPARING FOR PGPBA INTERVIEWS AT IIMB
lakshmymenon : Apart from the general questions (tell me about yourself, why MBA, questions about acads, work ex, home state, current affairs etc.), you must be prepared to answer questions such as Why BA, future of BA, Impact of AI in this field,General questions on AI and Machine Learnong, and questions related to data, statistics, coding (if you have a background) etc.


kenneth : SIR I HAVE ONLY CALL FROM SIES SHOULD I CONSIDER THIS OR GIVE ANOTHER ATTEMPT NEXT YR I AM A FRESHER GRADUATED LAST YR
lakshmymenon : Since you're a fresher, you should definitely consider another attempt if it's possible. You can find a job in the meanwhile if you would like to do something other than CAT preparation, but the gap per se does not matter much.


ayushi : HOW IS IIT JODHPUR??
siddhartharora : https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation Categorised as BBB+ by TIME


manas : SIR WHAT COULD I EXPEFT IIFTK'S PLACEMENT TO BE, AND CAN YOU RANK IIM RAIPUR, IIM RANCHI, IIM ROHTAK, BITSOM AND IIFTK...SO THAT I GET OVERALL STANDINGS OF THE INSTITUTES
siddhartharora : check here https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation


stats : DOES LIBA HAS 100% PLACEMENTS?CAN WE CONSIDER THIS INTO TOP BSCHOOL IN TN?
lakshmymenon : It is one of the better B-schools in Tamil Nadu. While they have 100 percent placements most years, it is not guaranteed. Please check our B-school ratings here: https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation


kenneth : SIR HOW IS SIES IN TERMS OF OVERALL PEDAGOGY IF I WANT TO DO MBA THIS YEAR ITSELF?
siddhartharora : It is a decent college, what exactly you want to know.


tk : SIR HOW IS SCMHRD BUSINESS ANALYTICS, SHOULD I CONSIDER BOOKING A SEAT , I HAD A CALL FROM ALL IITS AND IIM INDORE, SHILLONG , IIMB PGPBA, IIMK FINANCE AND MY PROFILE IS 9/8/8 WITH 2.5 YEARS OF WORK EX?
siddhartharora : It is good Institute but a specialised course, go for it if you have interest in the same or else wait for other Institutes results


hocc4z233 : WHAT SHOULD BE MY ORDER OF PREFERENCE FOR SIMS PUNE, SIBM BANGLORE, SIIB PUNE? I HAVE CONVERTED FIRST TWO SO FAR.
lakshmymenon : SIBM Bangalore and SIIB>SIMS


yash : SIR, I AM CURRENTLY EARNING AN ANNUAL SALARY OF GREATER THAN 40 LACS, WORKING IN SELL SIDE EQUITY RESEARCH. HOWEVER I DO NOT LIKE THE BACKEND NATURE OF WORK. STUDYING FROM WHICH IIM'S WOULD GIVE GOOD ROI CONSIDERING THE OPPORTUNITY COST? AND IS IT ADVISABLE TO PURSUE MBA FROM IIM'S AT THIS STAGE OF MY CAREER (2.5 YEAR WORK EX)
lakshmymenon : If you only look at immediate placements, there is no guarantee that you will get 40+lakhs on graduating from ANY top Bschool. However, ROI is to be considered in the long run - your long term placement prospects, the brand value etc. all matter. So, yes - an MBA at this stage is definitely worth it but you need to be realistic in your expectations.


stats : IS IIM 5 DAYS WORK OR 6 DAYS WORK?
siddhartharora : It is a residential program and classes can happen on any day. Office works 5 days a week


xxx : HOW IS IIT JODHPUR SME? ALREADY ANSWERED BUT ITS SHOWING PAGE NOT FOUND
siddhartharora : Categorised as BBB+ by TIME


bhargav : SIR, I AM IN WORKING PROFESSION, IS THERE ANY DIFFERENCE WHILE PURSUING MBA THROUGH ONLINE RATHER THAN OFFLINE?
siddhartharora : Online has no value for placements


stats : IS THERE ANY SCHOLARSHIP FOR SC STUDENTS IN IIM FEES? WHERE TO CHECK IT?
lakshmymenon : You can apply for the Central Sector SC scholarship through the college, once you join.


kenneth : SIR I WANT TO KNOW IF SIES IS GOOD FOR MBA AND IF IT IS A GOOD OPTION FOR ME FOR COLLEGES IN NAVI MUMBAI / MUMBAI?
lakshmymenon : It is rated BBB - https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation. It is a good enough Bschool with a placement package of about 10 lpa (average) if you do not want to repeat CAT.


hocc4z233 : ANY PLATFORM WHERE I CAN CHECK FOR UPDATES ON FINAL MERIT LISTS BEING RELEASED BY INSTITUTES? AS MOST OF THEM DO NOT SEND REJECTION MAILS.
philipthomas : The T.I.M.E. website provides it under alerts.


harsh : SIR I HAVE DONE MY BACHELORS IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING 2019-23 AND POST GRADUATION I HAVE WORKED IN BFSI SECTOR FOR 4 MONTHS IN SALES VERTICAL AND I DO HAVE A GAP OF APPROX 1.5 YRS POST MY GRADUATION. I HAVE CONVERTED SIDTM AND BIMTECH GENERAL MBA PROGRAMME TILL DATE. I AM NOT CLEAR WITH THE STREAM I SHOULD PURSUE AN MBA IN; LOOKING AT MY OPTIONS WHICH B SCHOOL SHOULD I GO FOR ?
siddhartharora : BIMTECH is a better choice here being a core program


dhruvil : CAN WE START CFA IN OUR FIRST YEAR MBA? I MEAN DO WE GET TIMES TO PREPARE?
siddhartharora : yes


dhruvil : CAN YOU RATE NMIMS CAMPUSES MUMBAI ,BANGALORE, NAVI MUMBAI, INDORE, HYDERABAD
siddhartharora : check here https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation


stats : DOES MBA IN ABROAD GREATER THAN IIMS?
siddhartharora : depends on the college


manas : SIR IIFTK AFTER SEPARATION, WHAT COULD BE THE AVG PLACEMENT WHICH WE CAN EXPECT, AND CAN YOU RANK, IIM RAIPUR, IIM RANCHI, IIM ROHTAK AND IIFTK
philipthomas : Average placement is 29 lakhs. IIFTK outranks these 3 IIMs.


kenneth : SIR HOW IS LONG TERM ROI FROM SIES AND CAN I SHIFT TO FINANCE SECTOR AS I GRADUATED WITH A MARKETING DEGREE ,BUT I AM INTERESTED IN FINANCE IS IT POSSIBLE ?
siddhartharora : shift yes, but ROI depends as packages offered at SIES are mostly up to 10 LPA


hoo : XIMB MMS BF OR SOIL
lakshmymenon : XIMB


yash : CONTINUING ON MY PREVIOUS QUESTION, GETTING AN MBA FROM IIM A AND B WOULD MAKE SENSE RIGHT? (NOTWITHSTANDING THE IMMEDIATE PACKAGE BUT THE BRAND VALUE AND LONG TERM PLACEMENT PROSPECTS)? ALSO, HOW WOULD IIM LUCKNOW RANK CONSIDERING EVERYTHING? AND, HOW DOES MBA FROM IIM ABC'S COMPARE TO MBA ABROAD?
siddhartharora : After ABC it is LIK and all 6 old IIMs rate very well in India. Coming to abroad again it depends on the college, a Havard will be ranked better but not every college


harsha : MA'AM/SIR IN WAT OF KJS SOMAIYA, I DIDNT WRITE EXACT THEME OF GIVEN TOPIC OF ETHICAL CONSUMERISM BUT MY ANSWER WAS SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT (FEW LINES) , CAN I EXPECT ATLEAST SOME SCORE FOR WAT
lakshmymenon : Definitely, as long as you have written something on the topic from multiple perspectives.


dhruvil : WHAT IS THE PROCESS OF IFMR INTERVIEW
siddhartharora : it is a normal interview, what exactly you want to know


manas : SIR IIFTK'S PLACEMENT IS 29LPA BECAUSE THEY HAVE COMMON PLACEMENT AS OF NOW, THE SCENARIO COULD BE DIFFERENT ONCE IT SEPRATES FROM DELHI
siddhartharora : yes it is very likely


vaibhav : SIR, JOINING TISS FOR HR ROLE IS WORTH IT IN LONG TERM?
lakshmymenon : Absolutely - it is one of the best colleges in India for HR and has excellent brand value.


thinesh : BIM TRICHY OR KJ SOMAIYA WHICH ONE IS BEST?
philipthomas : K.J.Somaiya is the better choice


kenneth : SIR WHICH COLLEGES ARE MOST PREFERABLE IF I REPEAT CAT AGAIN BUT AROUND MUMBAI ,PUNE LOCATION WISE?
philipthomas : The following colleges would top the list ; JBIMS , IIM - M , IIT-B , SIBM PUNE , NMIMS MUMBAI and SCMHRD PUNE .


harsha : MA'AM/SIR IN LIBA INTERVIEW THEY ASKED WHAT OTHER COLLEGES U APPLIED. I MENTIONED 2-3 COLLEGES(BUT APPLIED MORE THAN 2). THEY WAITED SO I AM ABOUT TO SAY ANOTHER AND THEN THEY FINALLY WENT TO NEXT QUESTION. HOW DO YOU THINK I CAN EFFECTIVELY ANSWER THIS QUESTION
lakshmymenon : Your answer was just fine. If they ask you which is your first preference among those, be honest but diplomatic and give reasons for your preference.


harsh : SIR I AM A MECHANICAL ENGINEER SO WHAT SHOULD BE A RIGHT CHOICE BETWEEN SIOM AND BIMTECH CORE IF CONSIDERING A CAREER IN LONG TERM
siddhartharora : core is always good for long term


harsha : WELINGKAR, FORE DELHI, IMI KOLKATA, MY GDPI FOR THESE COLLEGES FEW WEEKS BACK ALREADY AND NO RESPONSE YET , MAY I KNOW WHEN CAN I EXPECT RESPONSE FROM THEM
philipthomas : You can expect the results any day between March 20th and April 10th.


srijan : SAME HERE NO RESPONSE FROM WELLINGKAR
philipthomas : Final selection list is expected to be announced between March 20 and April 10.


kenneth : SIR AFTER WHICH TIER/ RANKING YOU SHOULD NOT CONSIDER DOING MBA FROM AS PER TIME TIER LIST?
philipthomas : Stick to the top 100.


chandana : IMI KOLKATA VS XIME BANGLORE/CHENNAI
siddhartharora : https://www.time4education.com/CAT-MBA/About-MBA/TIME-B-School-Categorisation check here


harsh : SIR HOW IS BIMTECH CORE PROGRAMME AND IF COMPARED WITH NMIMS BANGALORE WHERE DOES IT STAND
philipthomas : NMIMS Bangalore is definitely a much better choice.


kenneth : SIR IS IT POSSIBLE TO SHIFT TO FINANCE THROUGH MBA ONLY OR SHOULD I ALSO GO FOR SOME PROFESSIONAL COURSES LIKE CFA ETC?
philipthomas : You can shift to finance through an MBA.


harsha : ALSO LAST ONE: MAY I KNOW WHETHER INTERVIEW CALLS FOR BITSOM MUMBAI STARTED OR NOT
siddhartharora : not yet